← All articles

Guide

Paying a contractor in Poland, India or the Philippines: what the US side files (1099-NEC or not, W-8BEN, FBAR) and what the local side expects

November 17, 2026

No 1099, one form kept on file, and the cases that change that. W-8BEN validity, the $2,000 1099-NEC threshold, when 1042-S and FBAR apply, the PE and misclassification lines in Poland, India and the Philippines, and a year of paperwork for three contractors paid $120,000.

A laptop showing a world map on a wooden desk below a cork world map on the wall

You found three good people: a developer in Kraków, one in Pune, a designer in Cebu. You are a small US company and you pay them by invoice. Then someone asks "do I send them a 1099?" and the answers online run from "yes, always" to "never, ignore it". The short truth for a contractor who lives and works abroad is no 1099, one form kept on file, and a short list of things that change that.

This is the paperwork file for those three people over one year: what the US side files, what it only keeps, what each home country expects from the contractor, and where the lines for permanent establishment (PE) and misclassification sit. The money side (what each route costs) is in our guide to hiring a developer abroad; the owner side is in paying yourself from a US LLC abroad. IRS statements below are quoted from IRS pages read in November 2026; country points come from local sources and are marked where they are secondary. This is general information, not tax or legal advice.

The three contractors we will use

text
Contractor      Home      Monthly invoice   Year (12 invoices)   Works from
-----------     --------  ----------------  -------------------  -------------------
Developer       Poland    $4,500            $54,000              Own flat, own laptop
Developer       India     $3,000            $36,000              Own flat, own laptop
Designer        Philippines $2,500          $30,000              Own home, own laptop
-----------     --------  ----------------  -------------------  -------------------
Total paid by the US company                $120,000

All three: individuals, not US citizens or green-card holders, paid in USD,
all work done at home, none has set foot in the US, no shared exclusivity.

The US side: file, keep, or nothing

The rule that decides almost everything is where the work is done. IRS Publication 515 puts it plainly: for pay for personal services, the source of the income is "where the services are performed", and "the place where the services are performed determines the source of the income, regardless of where the contract was made, the place of payment, or the residence of the payer". Work done in Kraków is foreign-source income, so the US withholding system (30% on US-source income of foreign persons) never starts. The 1099-NEC form is a different system, aimed at US persons, which is why it does not apply either.

text
Item                     For our three            What triggers it instead
-----------------------  -----------------------  ----------------------------------------
Form W-8BEN              Collect and KEEP         (Never filed with the IRS)
Form 1099-NEC            Not required             Contractor is a US citizen/resident (W-9)
Form 1042-S + Form 1042  Not required             Work done inside the US (US-source pay)
Backup withholding 24%   Not applicable           US person who gives no taxpayer number
FBAR (FinCEN 114)        Not required             YOUR company holds foreign accounts > $10,000
Deduction records        Keep                     Always

Form W-8BEN: the one form to collect

A W-8BEN is the contractor's signed statement that they are not a US person. You do not send it to the IRS; you keep it as the proof behind two decisions: no 1099, no withholding. The IRS instructions say a W-8BEN stays in effect from the date it is signed "and ending on the last day of the third succeeding calendar year, unless a change in circumstances makes any information on the form incorrect", with the example that a form signed 30 September 2015 is valid through 31 December 2018. So a form signed in 2026 is good through 31 December 2029.

What to check when it arrives (two minutes each):

text
[ ] Part I: legal name matches the invoice and the bank account name
[ ] Country of citizenship and permanent-residence address are both outside the US
[ ] No P.O. box and no US address as the permanent address
[ ] Foreign tax number filled in (PAN in India, NIP/PESEL in Poland, TIN in the Philippines)
[ ] Signed and dated, in the current calendar year
[ ] Filed with the contract, with the date it expires written on the folder

Strictly, an IRS rule does not say "you must collect a W-8BEN for foreign-source services". It is the evidence that makes the position defensible if the IRS ever asks why there is no 1099 and no withholding on $120,000 of payments. We treat it as required. Change in circumstances means: the contractor moves to the US, gets a green card, or starts doing the work from a US address. Ask for a new form at once.

The 1099-NEC: when a foreign address still needs one

The IRS instructions for the 1099-NEC say to use Form 1042-S "for payments to nonresident aliens", and that the form is for payments made "in the course of your trade or business". For payments made from 2026 the filing threshold is $2,000 (it was $600), with the form due, and sent to the contractor, on 31 January. A US citizen living in Poland is still a US person, so if our Kraków developer were one, the $54,000 would need a 1099-NEC and a W-9 on file.

text
What if the Kraków developer is a US citizen and never sent a W-9?
  Backup withholding rate (Pub. 515)          24%
  On $54,000 for the year                     $12,960 that should have been withheld
  1099-NEC                                    Due 31 January, sent to the contractor and filed
  Fix                                         Ask for a W-9 at onboarding. One question on the
                                              intake form: "US citizen or green-card holder?" 

Form 1042-S: the visit to New York

If the work is partly done in the US, Pub. 515 says the income must be accurately allocated between US and foreign work. Example: our Indian developer flies to New York for a three-week sprint, 15 working days out of about 250 in the year.

text
Year's pay                                   $36,000
US working days / all working days           15 / 250 = 6%
US-source part                               $36,000 x 6% = $2,160
Withholding at 30% (statutory rate)          $2,160 x 30% = $648
Forms                                        1042-S to the contractor and the IRS, plus Form 1042
                                             (both due 15 March)
Treaty exemption                             Possible under the US-India treaty for independent
                                             services, claimed on Form 8233; ask a preparer,
                                             do not guess

Two cheap ways to avoid this: do the New York days as a separate, paid-for visit with a line on the invoice (so the allocation is clean), or pay the 30% and let the contractor claim it back in their own country. What not to do is pay the whole invoice with no note and hope.

FBAR: only if the company holds foreign accounts

An FBAR is about your accounts, not the contractor's. The IRS page says a US person, "including a citizen, resident, corporation, partnership, limited liability company, trust and estate", must file an FBAR if it has a financial interest in or signature authority over a financial account outside the US and the aggregate value of those accounts "exceeded $10,000 at any time during the calendar year". It is due 15 April, with an automatic extension to 15 October, filed with FinCEN as Form 114.

For our three contractors you do not need a foreign account: pay them from your US bank or a payment service. It becomes your problem if you open a PLN, INR or PHP account in the company's name to pay them locally, or hold a payroll float abroad, and the balance passes $10,000 on any single day. The penalty amounts are set by FinCEN each January; the January 2025 inflation adjustment (90 FR 5629) puts the willful maximum at $165,353 per violation, and practitioner sources give the non-willful figure as $16,536. If you use a multi-currency service, ask your CPA whether balances held by its non-US entities count for your company; we did not find a single authoritative answer.

Deduction records: what a year of invoices needs

You deduct what you paid a foreign contractor as an ordinary business expense like any contract labour. With no 1099 there is no form to back it up, so the file has to: for each contractor and each month, the invoice, the proof of payment (bank line or transfer receipt) and the contract. Keep it at least as long as the return is open, which is three years in most cases; keeping seven costs nothing as PDFs.

The home-country side

The contractor is in charge of their own country's tax and registration. What the paying company still wants to know is that it is being done, because three things come back to you: an invoice that does not match the law of their country, a contractor who stops paying their own contributions, and a tax or labour office that decides the contractor was really an employee. Our own checks, per country:

text
                   Poland                 India                         Philippines
-----------------  ---------------------  ----------------------------  ---------------------------
Contractor is a    Sole proprietor (JDG)  Freelancer, GST-registered    Self-employed, BIR-registered
Your invoice       Issued by them, no     Export of services, zero-     Official receipt/invoice,
                   Polish VAT charged     rated (0% GST), under an LUT  foreign client
                   (B2B services to a     filed each year; LUT number
                   foreign company)       on the invoice
Their tax          PIT + ZUS, their own   Income tax; GST return for    8% on gross over PHP 250,000
                   monthly ZUS            exports (GSTR-1, GSTR-3B)     (if gross <= PHP 3 million),
                                                                        or graduated + 3% percentage tax
Proof of           Bank statement         e-FIRA / FIRC for each        Bank statement + official
payment                                   inward remittance             receipt
You withhold?      No                     No                            No (they file quarterly 1701Q)
-----------------  ---------------------  ----------------------------  ---------------------------

Some of the numbers behind this: India's GST registration threshold for services is INR 2,000,000 (20 lakh) a year; our Indian developer's $36,000 is roughly INR 3.2 million at about INR 88 to the dollar (our assumption, not a quote), above it, so they need a GSTIN and, to invoice without charging 18% IGST, a Letter of Undertaking filed on the GST portal each year (sources: winvesta, Masters India). In the Philippines the 8% option replaces the graduated income tax and the 3% percentage tax: for $30,000 at about PHP 58 to the dollar (again our assumption) that is gross PHP 1,740,000, less 250,000, times 8% = PHP 119,200 (about $2,055, 6.9% of gross) for the year. Poland's section is mostly invoices: the Polish developer charges no Polish VAT on services to a company outside the EU and notes the legal basis on the invoice; Poland's e-invoicing system (KSeF) became mandatory for VAT taxpayers from 1 February 2026 with a grace period to 31 July 2026, per Freenance.

Ask each contractor for one thing once a year: a one-line confirmation that they are registered and filing in their country (a screenshot of the registration, no tax details). You are not their accountant; you are checking that nothing will land on you.

Misclassification: where each country draws the line

All three countries look at how the work is actually done, not at the word "contractor" in the contract. The signals are close to the same everywhere. A year of working with each of our three shows where they differ:

text
Signal (yes = employee risk)                  PL     IN     PH
--------------------------------------------  -----  -----  -----
You set their working hours                    yes    yes    yes
They report to a manager inside your company   yes    yes    yes (control test)
They work only for you for 6+ months           yes    yes    yes
They use your laptop, accounts and email       yes    yes    yes
You can end the work without notice at will    yes    yes    yes (power of dismissal)
You pay a fixed monthly sum, no deliverables   yes    yes    yes (wages)
Same job as your own employees                 yes    yes    yes

What each country does with a yes:

text
Poland       Since 8 July 2026 the Labour Inspectorate (PIP) can turn a B2B contract
             into employment by decision, no court first. Fine up to EUR 15,000 per
             contract; tax and ZUS back payments up to five years; 30 days to appeal;
             12 months without PIP fines from July 2026 (not for tax or ZUS).
             Employer ZUS alone is about 20.48% of pay, so on $54,000 a year that is
             $11,059 a year, $55,296 over five years, before the employee share.
India        No single statute test. Courts weigh control, integration, exclusivity and
             who owns the tools. Risk if they win: provident fund (12% each side of
             basic wage), gratuity (15 days' wages per year of service after five years)
             and notice pay claims. A foreign company with no Indian entity is hard to
             enforce against, which is a reason to be careful, not a reason to be loose.
Philippines  The Supreme Court's four-fold test: who selects and engages, who pays
             wages, who can dismiss, and above all who controls HOW the work is done.
             If the answer is you, the worker is an employee: 13th-month pay (one
             twelfth of basic pay), 5 days of service incentive leave, SSS, PhilHealth
             and Pag-IBIG employer shares, and security of tenure.

The Polish row uses the same figures as in our hire-abroad cost guide; the Indian and Philippine rows are written from local sources (Gloroots, Triple i Consulting, Global Law Experts) and are a map for a conversation with a local lawyer, not an opinion. The gratuity and leave figures are the long-standing statutory ones.

Fixing a yes: three changes that cost nothing

text
1. Pay for deliverables or a sprint scope, not for hours at a desk.
2. Let them choose their hours; use a weekly demo, not a daily check-in.
3. Make sure they can work for others (remove any exclusivity clause) and use
   their own laptop and accounts, with access to your repo as a guest only.

Permanent establishment: does a contractor put your company in their country?

A PE is a taxable presence of a foreign company in a country. The usual triggers in the OECD model, which the US treaties with all three countries follow in outline, are a fixed place of business at your disposal, or a person acting for you who habitually concludes contracts in your name (a dependent agent). An independent developer who builds your product in their own flat, for several clients, is neither. Where it changes:

text
Safe (no PE)                       Look harder
---------------------------------  -------------------------------------------------
Builds what you specify, invoices  Signs contracts or accepts customer orders for you
Works at home on their own laptop  You rent or pay for an office or desk for them
Other clients exist                Their business cards and email show your company name
No authority to bind you           They run your local sales, support or hiring
                                   They have worked only for you for years

The treaty text matters too: read Article 5 of the US treaty with the country in question, or ask the preparer to. The IRS lists them at United States income tax treaties A to Z. We did not verify each treaty's services clock here, so we do not quote day counts. The practical rule: if you would be comfortable showing the contractor's setup to a local tax inspector, it is fine. If you are about to hire a second or third person in the same country, look at our first foreign subsidiary guide instead.

A year of paperwork for the three contractors

text
When                 Who        What
-------------------  ---------  -----------------------------------------------------
Before 1st payment   US co.     W-8BEN signed (or W-9 if a US person), contract signed,
                                IP assignment, 'US citizen or green card?' answered
Before 1st payment   Each       Registration proof: JDG (PL), GSTIN + LUT (IN), BIR (PH)
Every month          Each       Invoice (with LUT number for India; no VAT for Poland)
Every month          US co.     Match invoice to payment, file both, note any US days
Every quarter        US co.     Six-signal check above; log the answer
15 Mar               US co.     Form 1042-S and Form 1042, only if any US-source pay
15 Apr               US co.     FBAR for any foreign account > $10,000 (ext. to 15 Oct)
April (IN)           India      New LUT for the financial year, before the first invoice
15 May/Aug/Nov (PH)  Philippines Quarterly 1701Q (their filing, ask for confirmation)
31 Jan               US co.     1099-NEC: only for a US-person contractor, $2,000 or more
Yearly               US co.     Ask for confirmation of local registration; new W-8BEN
                                only when the old one expires or circumstances change

Count what is left for the US company with three foreign individuals who stay abroad: one form per person kept (three W-8BENs), twelve invoices and twelve payment records each, and a quarterly four-line check. No IRS filing at all unless something changes. The year goes wrong only if it quietly changes: a visit, a move, an office, a contractor who becomes your full-time colleague.

What can change the answer

text
Event                                        New obligation
-------------------------------------------  ----------------------------------------
Contractor moves to the US                   New W-8BEN or W-9; 1099-NEC; maybe withhold
Contractor takes a US green card             W-9, 1099-NEC, backup withholding risk
Work done on a US trip                       Allocate; 1042-S/1042 and 30% unless treaty
You open a PLN/INR/PHP account               FBAR if the total passes $10,000 any day
Second and third hire in the same country    PE and entity question; see subsidiary guide
Contractor works only for you, 6+ months     Re-run the six-signal check, then consider EOR

Writing up the work before you hire? The developer brief tool turns your idea into a one-page brief a contractor can quote on: scope, must-haves, what done looks like and the questions they will ask. A clear scope is also the best protection against the 'employee in disguise' signals above. Free, in your browser.

Open the developer brief tool

Sources

US: IRS Instructions for Form W-8BEN (expiry of a W-8BEN); IRS: Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) ($10,000, 15 April, 15 October, who must file); IRS Publication 515 (source of personal-services income, 30% withholding, 24% backup withholding, Form 1042-S); IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC (Form 1042-S for nonresident aliens, $2,000 threshold from 2026, 31 January); Federal Register: FinCEN inflation adjustment of civil monetary penalties, 17 January 2025; Taxes for Expats: Form 1099 for foreign contractors. Countries (secondary sources, checked November 2026): Legal 500: reclassification of B2B into employment in Poland; Freenance: ZUS and KSeF in Poland 2026; Winvesta: LUT for export of services and Masters India: freelancer GST on exports; Mellow: freelance taxes in the Philippines (8% option); Gloroots: Philippines contractor regulations and Global Law Experts: employee vs independent contractor in the Philippines. The exchange rates, worked numbers and the three-contractor year are our own assumptions and calculations. This is a paperwork guide, not tax or legal advice: have a US preparer and a local adviser confirm your position before you rely on it.